Elderly woman falls on the steps as her husband looks on and yells for help.
Premises liability is the concept that property owners have a duty of care to ensure the safety of pedestrians, and any other people who enter the property.

What is Premises Liability?

Premises liability is a fundamental area of California personal injury law that holds property owners and occupiers responsible for accidents and injuries that occur on their property. This legal concept is based on the principle that those who control property have a duty to maintain safe conditions for visitors and warn them of potential hazards.

Legal Duty of Care in California

Under California law, property owners and occupiers owe different levels of care to different categories of visitors. Understanding these distinctions is crucial for both property owners and those who may have been injured on someone else’s property.

Invitees

Invitees are individuals who enter the property for business purposes that benefit the property owner. This category includes customers in stores, patients in medical offices, and clients visiting professional services. Property owners owe the highest duty of care to invitees and must:

  • Regularly inspect the property for hazards
  • Promptly repair known dangers
  • Provide adequate warning of existing hazards that cannot be immediately fixed
  • Maintain the property in a reasonably safe condition
  • Exercise reasonable care to discover any hidden dangers

Licensees

Licensees enter the property for their own purposes with the owner’s permission. Social guests are the most common example of licensees. Property owners owe licensees a moderate duty of care, which includes:

  • Warning about known hazards that might not be obvious
  • Maintaining the property in a reasonably safe condition
  • Repairing dangerous conditions or providing adequate warning

Trespassers

Trespassers enter property without permission. While property owners owe the lowest duty of care to trespassers, they still must:

  • Refrain from willfully or wantonly causing injury
  • Warn of artificial conditions that could cause death or serious injury if they know trespassers are likely to be present

Special considerations apply to child trespassers under the “attractive nuisance” doctrine, which requires additional precautions for features that might attract children, such as swimming pools or construction equipment.

Common Types of Premises Liability Cases

Slip and Fall Accidents

Slip and fall cases are the most common type of premises liability claim in California. These accidents can occur due to:

  • Wet or slippery floors
  • Uneven surfaces
  • Poor lighting
  • Broken stairs or handrails
  • Debris or obstacles in walkways
  • Weather-related hazards
  • Recently mopped or waxed floors

Property owners must take reasonable steps to prevent these conditions or warn visitors about them. This includes regular maintenance, prompt cleanup of spills, and proper warning signs.

Inadequate Security

Property owners may be liable for criminal acts that occur on their property if they failed to provide adequate security measures. This is particularly relevant for:

  • Apartment complexes
  • Shopping centers
  • Parking structures
  • Hotels
  • Office buildings
  • Educational institutions

Reasonable security measures might include:

  • Proper lighting
  • Security cameras
  • Access control systems
  • Security personnel
  • Sturdy locks and doors
  • Emergency response systems

Defective Property Conditions

These cases involve injuries caused by structural defects or poor maintenance:

  • Collapsed stairs or railings
  • Faulty electrical wiring
  • Ceiling or wall collapse
  • Toxic mold exposure
  • Carbon monoxide leaks
  • Fire hazards
  • Building code violations

Establishing Liability in California

To succeed in a premises liability claim, the injured party must prove several elements:

1. Duty of Care

The plaintiff must establish that the property owner owed them a duty of care based on their status as an invitee, licensee, or trespasser.

2. Property Control

The defendant must have owned, leased, occupied, or controlled the property where the injury occurred. Multiple parties may share control and liability, such as:

  • Property owners
  • Property management companies
  • Tenants
  • Maintenance contractors
  • Security companies

3. Dangerous Condition

The plaintiff must prove that a dangerous condition existed on the property. This requires showing:

  • The condition created an unreasonable risk of harm
  • The defendant knew or should have known about the condition
  • The condition was not obvious to a reasonable person

4. Notice

The property owner must have had either:

  • Actual notice: Direct knowledge of the dangerous condition
  • Constructive notice: The condition existed long enough that it should have been discovered through reasonable inspection

5. Causation and Damages

The plaintiff must demonstrate that:

  • The dangerous condition was a substantial factor in causing their injury
  • They suffered actual damages as a result

Defenses to Premises Liability Claims

Property owners may assert various defenses to liability:

Comparative Negligence

California follows pure comparative negligence, meaning damages are reduced by the percentage of fault attributed to the plaintiff. Common examples include:

  • Failing to pay attention to obvious hazards
  • Ignoring warning signs
  • Entering restricted areas
  • Wearing inappropriate footwear
  • Engaging in dangerous activities

Open and Obvious Doctrine

Property owners may not be liable for injuries caused by conditions that are:

  • Clearly visible
  • Known to the injured party
  • Obviously dangerous to a reasonable person

However, this defense may be limited if:

  • The dangerous condition was unavoidable
  • The property owner should have anticipated harm despite the obvious nature of the hazard

Assumption of Risk

This defense applies when the injured party:

  • Knew of the specific risk
  • Understood the danger
  • Voluntarily exposed themselves to the hazard (“assumed the risk“)

Lack of Control

Defendants may argue they:

  • Did not own or control the property
  • Had no authority to fix the condition
  • Were not responsible for the area where the injury occurred

Damages Available in Premises Liability Cases

California law allows recovery of various damages:

Economic Damages

These include quantifiable financial losses:

Non-Economic Damages

These cover subjective losses:

  • Pain and suffering
  • Emotional distress
  • Loss of enjoyment of life
  • Disfigurement
  • Loss of consortium
  • Anxiety and depression
  • PTSD

Punitive Damages

While rare in premises liability cases, punitive damages may be available if the defendant’s conduct was:

  • Malicious
  • Fraudulent
  • Oppressive
  • Showing conscious disregard for safety

Statute of Limitations

California imposes strict time limits for filing premises liability claims:

  • Personal injury cases: 2 years from the date of injury
  • Property damage cases: 3 years from the date of damage
  • Government entity cases: 6 months to file an administrative claim

Exceptions may apply for:

  • Minors (toll until age 18)
  • Delayed discovery of injury
  • Defendant’s absence from the state
  • Mental incapacity

Special Considerations

Government Property

Claims involving public property require:

  • Filing an administrative claim within 6 months
  • Following specific procedural requirements
  • Meeting higher standards for proving dangerous conditions
  • Dealing with various immunities and exceptions

Commercial Properties

Business owners have additional obligations:

  • Compliance with building codes
  • ADA accessibility requirements
  • Health and safety regulations
  • Industry-specific standards
  • Regular safety inspections
  • Employee training programs

Residential Properties

Landlords must maintain:

  • Habitable living conditions
  • Working utilities
  • Secure doors and windows
  • Safe common areas
  • Proper fire safety equipment
  • Adequate lighting
  • Building code compliance

Risk Management and Prevention

Property owners should implement comprehensive risk management strategies:

Regular Inspections

  • Document all inspections
  • Maintain inspection logs
  • Follow up on reported hazards
  • Keep maintenance records
  • Photograph conditions regularly

Written Policies

  • Maintenance procedures
  • Safety protocols
  • Emergency response plans
  • Training requirements
  • Reporting mechanisms
  • Documentation standards

Insurance Coverage

  • Adequate liability limits
  • Appropriate policy types
  • Regular policy reviews
  • Prompt claim reporting
  • Risk assessment updates

Working with an Attorney

A premises liability attorney can:

  • Evaluate claim validity
  • Identify responsible parties
  • Gather evidence
  • Handle insurance companies
  • Calculate damages
  • Navigate legal procedures
  • Negotiate settlements
  • Represent clients in court

Conclusion

Premises liability law in California provides important protections for individuals injured on another’s property while imposing significant responsibilities on property owners. Understanding these rights and obligations is crucial for both property owners and potential plaintiffs. Whether you’re a property owner seeking to prevent liability or an injured party seeking compensation, consulting with an experienced premises liability attorney here at Woolf Legal can help ensure your legal rights are protected.

Have you been injured?

Schedule a no-cost consultation today!

We are here to help and guide you through the entire legal process.